5 Unique Thrift Shops in Elizabeth
Looking for the best thrift and antique shops in Elizabeth, NJ? From budget-friendly clothing and accessories to rare collectibles and vintage décor, these five local spots offer something for every treasure hunter.
If you’re after a unique fashion find, a statement furniture piece, or a nostalgic collectible, you’ll discover plenty of reasons to shop secondhand in Elizabeth.
Inspirations
Location: 1055 Elizabeth Avenue
Inspirations offers a mix of new and gently used apparel, shoes, and accessories for the whole family. With unbeatable prices and quality finds, this second-hand store is a great spot to find unique items for everyday wear.
“I love this place! Can't beat their prices or selection. Every time I go, I find the best t-shirts!” - Google
MyUnique Thrift Store
Location: 116 Broad Street
MyUnique Thrift is a go-to destination for secondhand treasures, vintage fashion, and home goods, all at everyday low prices. With fresh inventory arriving daily, you’ll find a mix of clothing, furniture, electronics, and more to keep you looking fresh in any season. Keep an eye on their color-coded tags to score discounts of 25%, 50%, or even 75%, and check in regularly for new markdowns and hidden gems.
“The ladies' department has clothing from NWT to great vintage pieces; the clothes are always neat, clean, and ready for a new home. I love the housewares too.” - Google
Andamastore
Location: 1147 E Jersey Street
Andamastore may look unassuming from the outside, but inside, you’ll find fantastic items at discounted prices. The friendly staff and excellent customer service make shopping here a positive experience, with plenty of beautiful finds for your everyday needs.
“Modest on the inside but they truly had some fantastic stuff. The staff is very friendly and I had a super positive experience here. I highly recommend.” - Google
Union County Exchange
Location: 1173 Elizabeth Ave
Union County Exchange has been a local fixture in Elizabeth for nearly 17 years, offering an eclectic mix of vinyl records, comics, vintage magazines, action figures, instruments, game systems, electronics, tools, and even silver and gold jewelry. They’re always hunting for fun and unique finds to resell and encourage customers to bring in items they might be interested in buying.
“You honestly feel like you traveled back in time. Truly a treasure find here in Elizabeth, NJ. If you look for vintage finds and some good music, records, and CDs, check this place out.” - Google
Elizabeth Coin & Jewelry Exchange
Location: 248 N Broad Street
Elizabeth Coin & Jewelry Exchange specializes in buying gold, silver, coins, diamonds, antiques, collectibles, and even vintage toys or musical instruments. Whether it’s scrap gold, rare coins, or unique artwork, they offer cash on the spot for items of value, making it a trusted spot in Elizabeth for buying (and selling) treasured pieces.
“I've been going to the Elizabeth Coin & Jewelry Exchange since the early 90's as a kid just to look around at some of the cool and unique things within” - Yelp
Discover More Hidden Gems in Elizabeth
