The 13 Best Pizza Places in Elizabeth, NJ | Visit Elizabeth, New Jersey

We take pizza very seriously in Elizabeth, New Jersey. Yes, we’re close to New York City’s slices, but if you’re looking for true pizza hidden gems, you’ll just have to make your way to our side of the river. Get ready for large pies, unbeatable deals, and a plethora of your favorite toppings. And if you don’t believe us yet, we’ve also gathered reviews from Google, Tripadvisor, and Yelp to prove our case.

Mario’s Pizza

Location: 94 Front St
Operating for over 40 years, Mario’s Pizza never fails to impress with flavorsome slices, attentive services, and an inviting atmosphere. A casual lunch or dinner is a celebration that’s worthy of high quality pizza at Mario’s. Enjoy appetizers like the bruschetta and bacon fries. Don’t leave out dessert at this spot! The Nutella pizza will surprise your taste buds with chocolatey hazelnut goodness.

“The food here is delicious. The people are down to earth and super friendly, and if you are looking for an intimate dining experience that won't break the bank, hit up Mario's.” - Yelp

Leo's Pizzeria & Deli

Location: 136 Broad St
Leo’s Pizzeria & Deli has achieved the golden balance between softness and crispiness when it comes to savory pies. Situated in Elizabeth’s Midtown area, this pizzeria serves up meatballs, mushrooms, peppers, and all of the classic toppings in spades. If you don’t feel hungry yet by our description, step inside this eatery and you’ll soon discover why Leo’s has been a local go-to spot.

“Really excellent pizza, good vibes, and a great place for a late night slice.” - Google

Eli’s Pizza and Pasta

Location: 766 Trumbull St
With housemade cheese and ingredients that are imported from Italy, you can’t go wrong with any savory pie at Eli’s Pizza and Pasta. This casual pizzeria is perfect for a cozy date or an outing with a small group of friends. Here, the crust is just the right amount of crispiness and the toppings don’t overpower the base flavor of the pie. Our personal favorites include the Sicilian and five cheeses pizzas.

“We found this jem by chance on a New York trip, better pizza than many in the city!” - Google

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Eli’s Pizza Pasta Pizzeria Ristorant (@elispizzapastanj)

Pizza Express

Location: 281 Westfield Ave
If you’re looking for a quick bite to go, Pizza Express has you covered. The garlic knots, loaded fries, and slices of pizza are calling your name. Choose between Hawaiian pizza, deep dish varieties, Buffalo chicken-topped slices, and more. Complete the order with Colombian sides like salchipapa or mazorcada.

“The pizza was very good, crust was perfect. This may become our new usual place. I would highly recommend.” - Google

Crust Pizza

Location: 429 N Broad St
Locally praised for a 22-inch pie, Crust Pizza is all about generous portions and affordable prices. Satisfy your appetite during late night hours with pizza toppings like bacon, olives, jalapenos, and pepperoni. With a courteous staff and giant slices that aren’t flimsy, Crust Pizza is a cheese- and tomato sauce-topped answer to your cravings.

“Fresh, hot, delicious and the biggest pie in the Tri-State.” - Yelp

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Crust Pizza (@crustpizzanj)

Michelino’s Restaurant

Location: 169 Washington Ave
Michelino’s Restaurant isn’t your typical Italian restaurant; decadent pizzas, pastas, and desserts are cooked and baked to authentic magnificence. After enjoying the pizza, prepare for decadent wines and creamy tiramisu.

“Great food, ambiance, and friendly helpful staff.” - Tripadvisor

Tommy’s Pizzeria

Location: 1063 Fairmount Ave
There’s just something about Tommy’s Pizzeria that evokes a chef’s kiss. Maybe it’s the housemade tomato sauce or the scrumptious crust. Some may claim that the pizza magic may lie in the fresh cheese. Or perhaps things taste better when the services are kind and thoughtful. We like to think that everyone comes back for all of the above: the ingredients, friendly staff, and expertly prepared pizza.

“The pizza was delicious, great flavorful crust and sauce, good balance of toppings.” - Google

Bella Pizza

Location: 5 Broad St B
This family-operated pizza place serves mouthwatering deep dish Margherita pie; close your eyes and you can almost taste the stunning harmony of marina sauce, fresh basil, and mozzarella cheese. If you want to make this dream into a reality, Bella Pizza sells it for eight slices at just $23.95.

“Just came in to get two slices and they are delicious. I’m always looking for a nice crunchy crust with right amount of cheese. They did not disappoint.” - Google

Bruno’s Pizzeria

Location: 500 Morris Ave
Bruno’s Pizzeria has two types of customers: regulars, and new visitors who are about to become regulars. This is a pizza haven that doesn’t skimp out on the toppings. If you like thin crust and an abundance of cheese, you’ll be sure to always have a good meal waiting for you at Bruno’s Pizzeria.

“The best pizza I ever tasted! It tastes so good, I've eaten that pizza ever since I've lived in Elizabeth.” - Tripadvisor

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Bruno’s Pizzeria (@brunos_pizzeria_official)

Elizabeth Pizzeria

Location: 871 Elizabeth Ave
Elizabeth Pizzeria brings Naples cuisine to this part of New Jersey with nonna-approved pies. From thin crust specialties to mouthwatering Sicilian pizzas, you certainly won’t leave hungry. Enjoy the pizzeria’s clean and well-maintained surroundings, as well as the speedy and welcoming services.

“A stuffed pizza was a unique experience for us and we loved it. The order came with a huge side of red sauce to dip and the size was great for the price.” - Google

Jersey Pizza USA

Location: 829 Elizabeth Ave
If you like good deals and thick-crust pies, Jersey Pizza is the place for you. This is no reheat-in-a-microwave eatery; all pies are fresh out of the oven and are ready to go at your convenience. Enjoy a budget-friendly feast with a pizza and wings combo, and don’t forget to add on your choice of soda.

“Very good quality for the price and lots of cheese!” - Yelp

John’s Caffe Pizza & Caterers

Location: 574 2nd Ave
Located on the corner of 2nd Avenue, John’s Caffe Pizza & Caterers is a small Elizabeth treasure, brimming with delightful pies, espresso, and more. The Sicilian pizza is an absolute delight with tangy tomato sauce, and an airy, focaccia-like crust.

“Loved walking into a restaurant that has history, and the food was amazing!” - Google

PieZano’s Pizza Kitchen

Location: 837 Grove St
PieZano’s has unlocked a Goldilock's predicament of pizza, using just the right amount of mozzarella, garlic, and tomato sauce. Along with classic varieties, we also recommend taking a bite out of the clams pizza or the baked ziti pie.

“The single slices are so good, especially the artichoke cheese (chicken on top) pizza and the chicken parmesan.” - Google

Elizabeth boasts a wide variety of pizzerias that offer one-of-a-kind slices! Get your savory pie fix in Elizabeth, where our eateries rival the ones across the Hudson River. For more food recommendations, check out our dining guide here.